The Revolution Will Not Be Telegraphed
[Abstract]
How does control over information shape the outcome of an autocratic transition? This paper studies a well-known strategy of autocrats in times of political instability: cutting off horizontal communications between civilians while saturating vertical communication channels with propaganda in the context of a coup against a democratic regime. More specifically, it explores the role of vertical broadcasts from the capital in preventing the coordination of pro-democracy citizens while securing the realignment of state agents. Based on Louis-Napoleon Bonaparte’s coup in December 1851 that caused the breakdown of the Second Republic (1848-1852), I study the effect of delays in telegraphic communications between Paris and the départements on the dynamics of local pro-democracy protests in a context characterized by near absolute censorship. I collected and digitized the full record of telegraphic dispatches exchanged between the capital and the rest of France during the coup. This rich dataset allows an examination of the effects of vertical information flows on mobilization and realignment. I model the stream of official communications during the coup through a simulation, and find that when the coup-plotters controlled information flows in and out of the capital, they could prevent the rise of pro-democracy dissent and clear the path towards autocracy. By contrast, when communications with Paris were less reliable and updates less frequent, I show that anti-coup mobilization was more likely and I provide descriptive evidence that local bureaucrats tended to be slower to realign with the new authoritarian regime.